College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Former prof dies after shuttle fall

By Michael McFall

News Editor

|

Published: Friday, November 20, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, December 1, 2009

shuttle

Mike Mangum/The Daily Utah Chronicle

The campus shuttles are being looked at after a former professor fell out of one and died. The shuttles undergo regular maintenance at mile intervals and state tests once a year.

A former professor died Thursday night after falling out of a moving shuttle. 

The 63-year-old woman, whose identity has not been released, fell out of a U campus shuttle at about 8:20 p.m., as it took a left turn from North Campus Drive to Mario Capecchi Drive, according to the U Police Department. 

The woman was standing on the steps in front of the rear doors, since all of the shuttle seats were occupied. During the turn, she stumbled and reached out to grab a handle or a bar but failed. She fell against the doors, which gave way just enough for her to fall out. 

“It happened so fast,” said Lauren McKay, a freshman who was sitting near the woman in the back of the shuttle. “She was there, and then she was gone. It could’ve happened to anyone.” 

Alyssa Spencer, who was sitting between McKay and the woman, saw the woman fall and screamed. The shuttle driver stopped when he heard his passengers crying out that something terrible had happened. 

“It was awful,” said Spencer, a junior in family studies. “I was really freaking out.” 

U Police responded to the call. The woman, whose head had hit the ground, was alive but unconscious when paramedics arrived and transported her to the University Hospital emergency room. She died from her injuries about two hours later at the hospital, after she was taken off respiratory therapy. 

U Police have not released the woman’s name, as they have not been able to identify her next of kin. Officers went to her apartment Thursday night hoping to find someone there, but she lives alone, said Sgt. Mike McPharlin. Investigators tried to figure out who her family members are by talking to her co-workers Friday, but so far, they’ve hit a brick wall. 

She adopted an English name when she came to the U from China more than nine years ago, which complicates the search for her family. She was a professor at the U in 2000 and became a naturalized citizen in 2003 but was no longer working at the U at the time of her death, said U spokesman Remi Barron. 

m.mcfall@chronicle.utah.edu

 

 

 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

30 comments

Connie McManus
Fri Nov 27 2009 12:35
I am really saddened to hear of this accident and wish to extend to this woman's family and friends my deepest condolences. But I must say, there should be a policy in place that prohibits standing on buses. This includes the UTA buses. If we can't allow passengers in personal vehicles to go about without being strapped into seat belts, why should public transportation allow passengers to stand? If there are so many passengers that there aren't enough seats for everyone, then the buses need to run extra buses to accomidate the demand. I would like to see the shuttle employees -management and drivers alike -- give a handsome compensation to this woman's family and change their policies to make a safer experience for all passengers.
Your name
Tue Nov 24 2009 14:39
BE A GENTLEMAN! I see so many men who do not give up their seats for women or the elderly. Where were you people raised?!! The next time I see a man rush in front of me to get onto the bus, or take a seat while a woman or elderly person stands, I am going to call you out and embarass the **** out of you! BE A GENTLEMAN you freaks!
RRE
Tue Nov 24 2009 11:16
i have been thinking about this for days....very sad and unfortunate to say the least!
i myself ride the shuttle everyday, and have for YEARS and some of those times have been scary,
i hate to stand in them and i will wait for the next one whether i'm late or not...sitting in the shuttles
with no seat belt is also very dangerous- landing on someone elses lap or on the floor.
my thought these past days- why didn't anyone offer this older lady their seat?
maybe if they would have then this tragedy would not have happened........
Your name
Tue Nov 24 2009 02:48
After seeing people get closed in doors, being thrown from their seats and watching drivers speed across corners and drive off without making sure their passengers are seated and safe (not to mention fitting so many people into the bus that people had to stand on the steps), I'm surprised that this tragedy hasn't occurred sooner. My heart goes out to this victim of negligence, and it's about time that someone force the commuter services to do something about their dangerous drivers and unsafe shuttles. By no means am I suggesting that all the drivers are bad, because some of them are quite good, but this is ridiculous.
Daily Shuttle rider- Freshman @ the U
Tue Nov 24 2009 02:21
This article scares me so much. That's so sad that her life ended so unexpectedly. I feel for the driver too, whether the driver's fault or not, that would be very traumatic.

I was so shocked when I had heard about this because in the previous week I sent out an email to the commuter's office and told them about a bad experience I had had on the shuttles. I wrote that not only was I hurt but reckless driving is a danger to everyone. With all of the stories of people getting caught in doors and thrown around, its hard to believe that this was merely a "mechanical failure". Since I've started here this year I've ridden the shuttles every day and I've seen scary things happen like bus drivers start to leave when people are entering or exiting and people being knocked around and onto the floor, as I was. ( I was thrown onto the floor when a driver came to a screeching halt and I weigh almost 300 lbs, imagine that)

Something DEFINATELY needs to be done. There needs to be reform. The ridiculous schedules of the shuttles need to change and the buses need their brakes and doors checked frequently. There is such a rush for the drivers to be '"on time" that they feel they need to drive quickly and this quickly turns into reckless driving. I already had thoughts about suing (to scare them into changing mostly) but now I feel like I should print out all of these stories and post them on their front door!

My last thought is about the training. The training procedures are downright unsafe. The trainees are driving students and professors around! Yes, there is always a more experienced driver guiding them but this does not prevent accidents.
I've been driven a two shuttle trainees since I've been here and both experiences were scary. The first case was when the trainee almost had a collision with a little red sports car in a round-a-bout. We were almost 2 feet away from hitting it and on top of that everyone on the shuttle was flung forward , some from their seats completely.
Second, I was riding a shuttle to the dorms and was sitting near the front of the bus when a driver was being trained and was listening to what he was saying. The trainer would say something like, "this is how we do this okay, it might be a pain but we have to keep safety in mind." and the numbskull would argue with almost everything the trainer said! I hope that person was not hired and I hope the driver I reported was fired.

A
Mon Nov 23 2009 19:19
Why on a bus full of college students is a 63 year-old woman standing? What happened to offering your seat to the elderly? Inconsiderate if you ask me.
Rick Astley
Mon Nov 23 2009 14:45
well hell, those doors are faulty anyways. I have seen multiple busses where only one of the back doors will open, and then the other will open later somewhat spontaneously, even if the bus is moving. IIRC, those doors have broken a few windows on the bus as well
Not taking the shuttle
Mon Nov 23 2009 11:24
I have been hurt and physically thrown about the shuttles when riding them!! a lot of the drivers are reckless and take those turns on North Campus Drive going way over ther speed limit!

Riding the shuttles is just an accident waiting to happen!!! I hope They learn from this event that they do not need to drive at 45 mph when the speed limit is 30!!!

TearsTheWingsOffAngels
Mon Nov 23 2009 08:52
I ride the shuttle all the time, and I've never found the drivers to be reckless. Chalk this up to accident: they do happen.
Your name
Sun Nov 22 2009 20:46
THE ACCIDENT CANT BE BLAMED ON ONE THING IT COULD BE THE DOOR WAS FAULTED ALSO THE DRIVER. I KNOW THE DRIVERS ARE TOLD OVER AND OVER TO MAKE SURE THAT EVERYONE IS SEATED BEFORE PROCEEDING.IF YOU GET BEHIND IN TIME SO WHAT YOU CAN GET CAUGHT UP. TIME DOESNT MATTER WHEN IT COMES TO PEOPLES SAFETY, SOME OF THE DRIVERS ARE RECTLESS AND DONT USE COMMON SENSE,WHICH IS NEEDED, THE SPEED LIMIT SHOULD BE INFORCED MORE,ALSO THERE ARE CARS THAT CUT THE DRIVERS OFF TIME AND TIME AGAIN,THE DRIVERS ARE EXAMINED ON THEIR DRIVING OFTEN. IF YOU KNOW SOMEONE WHO IS RECKLESS IN THEIR DRIVING TAKE THEIR NAME FROM THEIR SHIRT AND REPORT IT THATS WHY THEY HAVE THE NAME ON THE SHIRT. IM VERY SORRY THAT SOMEONE HAD TO DIE AND IM SURE THE DRIVER HAD TO TAKE A DRUG TEST RIGHT AFTER IT HAPPEN. IT IS GETTING TO BE WINTER SO BE CAREFUL IN ENTERING AND EXITNG THE BUSES. THE DRIVERS DO GO THRU AN INSPECTION OF THE BUSES EVERY MORNING BEFORE GETTING ON ROUTE,IF THEY FIND ANYTHING WRONG THEY DO A LOG SHEET WHERE THEY WRITE IT DOWN FOR THE MECHANJCS TO FIX IF ITS THE DOORS THEY TAKE IT OFF ROUTE AND FIX IT, DRIVING AT THE U CAN BE, STRESSFUL WITH ALL THE CARS THAT DO NOT OBEY THE ROAD RULES ,LIKE DISTANCE,STOPPING AT STOP SIGN, LOOK BEFORE CROSSING THE ROAD WHEN THE LIGHT SAYS NOT TO. RUNNING RED LIGHT ,ALWAYS THERE.ALSO THEY NEED MORE TICKETS GIVEN OUT BY POLICE, IF THE POLICE WOULD GO UNDERCOVER AND RIDE THE SHUTTLE SOMETIME THEY COULD FIND OUT WHERE PEOPLE ARE COMMITING ALL THE INFRACTION ,THAT NEED TO BE CORRECTED, BY TICKETING THE DRIVERS. DRIVERS SHOULD GO AT A SAFE SPPED AROUND CURVES , I HOPE THAT THE STUDENT WILL RIDE THE SHUTTLES ,BECAUSE THATS WHAT THEY ARE FOR. WITH THEPARKING LOTS BEING CUT DOWN ,.ALSO IF THERE IS A DRIVER YOU LIKE AND YOU FEEL SAFE WITH RIDE THEIR BUS,IF IT MEANS WAITING ON THEIR DUS. I USE TO DRIVE THERE ,SO I KNOW ALL THE LITTLE QUIRTS THEY CAN HAPPEN,ALSO THE DRIVERS GET TO MEET A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO BECOMES THERE FRIENDS AND I WOULDNT HAVE MISSED THAT FOR ANYTHING , BECAUSE IVE LOVED ALL THE STUDENTS THERE WHERE SOME COULD BE UNFRIENDLY AT TIMES BE WE ALL ARE THAT WAY, MAY ALL THE STUDENT THERE THIS YEAR HAVE A GREAT ONE ,AND ALL DRIVERS PLEASE SLOW DOWN AND BE SAFE. GOD BLESS YOU ALL
k
Sun Nov 22 2009 12:16
that turn up to fort douglas is very sharp. i work up there. the buses are always crowded. quick stops and goes because the buses are designed like big boxes and under them are big wheels. being an older lady i feel i am not as coordinated and strong as most of the younger students. maybe a change to newer bus shuttles where you can sit down. right? safer, smaller, and older people like me won't be a risk while trying to get to work.
Jason
Sun Nov 22 2009 00:43
My thoughts go out to the victim's family. I think it's premature to assume that this accident was due to recklessness on the part of the driver. But at the same time, I do hope all the comments on this site and also on the S. L. Tribune's site encourage the administration to review safety concerns about the shuttle system. Although I rarely ride the shuttles, I often fear for my safety when trying to park my car in the lots on the Eastern edge of the medical campus. The shuttles (and to be fair, other vehicles as well) FLY through those parking lots at extremely high rates of speed and trying to get in or out of a parking space when one is coming is downright scary. I always suspected that was the accident waiting to happen.
annie
Sat Nov 21 2009 13:52
Those drivers are a menace to the passengers. A couple of days ago, as I was getting out through the rear door, the driver shut off the doors on my body! I tried to release myself but in the end my foot was trapped and the driver started moving the shuttle! I mean: How negligent! I don't even want to imagine what would have happened hadn't the students inside yelled at his to stop. I was furious and yelled at him to be careful once he stopped, but he didn't even apologize. I believe his name was Jamie or Jay or something like that. Reckless.
king9sun
Sat Nov 21 2009 11:35
I feel very sad and sorry for her. It is our fault! The comments posted here have shown that many people (including me) have very bad experience in taking shuttle with some crazy drivers. We are never aware of that could kill us. If we can not come up with effective measure to be taken to restrain the crazy driver’s behaviors, the similar bad things would happen to some of us again sooner or later.
YY
Sat Nov 21 2009 01:12
Totally agree with Rich. I was thrown to against the rear door several times when the shuttles took right turns. Even though I was on the seat, I was still thrown away. Fortunately, The door was close. Please keek the shuttle in good conditions and Please hire some nice shuttle drivers to avoid this kind of accidents and save people's lives!!!
vicent
Fri Nov 20 2009 22:32
the driver should make sure the senior or disabled to sit before moving the bus.
the inevitable
Fri Nov 20 2009 21:58
What happened yesterday could only be contributed to one of two things: human error or mechanical failure. Even though the investigation has not yet been concluded, and the cause determined, and by no means am I engaging in any reckless speculation or drawing any premature conclusions, common sense would tell you, though possible, it was very unlikely it was mechanical. This leaves only the victim and the driver. I doubt the victim did anything to contribute to her death. It was only a matter of time before this tragedy happened. I and my friends have a had similar experiences when the shuttle driver started to drive off while we were still exiting/entering the shuttle. I, my friends, and family have talked about the dangerous circumstances the shuttles have posed regarding the drivers. We knew it was only a matter of time before there would be a fatality in this fashion. I don't care who the driver was, whether he was a student or not, or resided at the poor house. One should be a professional at all times while on the job. There is a principle in the transportatio industry that the operator is responsible for what happens unders his/her control whether it's his/her fault or not, just as a captain is responsible for everything that happens on his ship.
In regards to chad,'s previous psuedoliberalistic jabbering, his "open" mindedness is moronic and his logic convoluted. This is why the ignorant braindead should not be allowed to comment on anything except juvinile topics like which beanies to wear. Stick with what you know!
Shay
Fri Nov 20 2009 21:54
Have any of you taken into consideration that often times when a driver either slams on thier brakes or drives what may seem recklessly, it is because they have been cut off, or pulled in front of by another vehicle, and they are actually trying to avoid an accident, which would injur and possibly kill passengers as well as pedestrians and anyone else in the vasinity. I happen to personally know drivers and I know that they go through a daily and very thorough inspection and many safety precautions are taken. THIS DRIVER IS NOT TO BLAME AT ALL!!!!!
DD
Fri Nov 20 2009 19:19
Where there anyone else on the bus? We can't rule out that that shuttle driver is not responsible for this. The driver should be suspended during the investigation.
amy
Fri Nov 20 2009 16:10
I think this is just a really sad situation. Here she is a researcher, looking for a better opportunity here and is killed. This of her family back in China who has absolutely no idea what has happened, and probably won't for a few more days or even a week. It's a freak accident, and I don't think there is anyone to blame. I do believe that our shuttles need to looked into, and maybe should invest in safer shuttles. I myself while trying the steady myself in the shuttle standing up and stumbling a bit too. I think others can agree to that as well.






log out