College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

It's OK to come out now

Threat of swine flu greatly exaggerated

By Whitney Fitts

Staff Writer

Print this article

Published: Thursday, June 18, 2009

Updated: Thursday, June 18, 2009

If you’ve quarantined yourself from the outside world out of fear of the swine flu, then it’s about time you came back out.

Actually, the time to quarantine yourself never really happened--you just think it happened because that’s what the news, not your doctor, told you.

The truth of the matter is that despite all the talk, news coverage and respiratory masks that have been so prominent the past few months, the swine flu isn’t the daunting biological threat it has been made out to be.

“What the epidemiologists are seeing now with this particular strain of U.N. (swine flu) is that the severity of the flu--how sick you get--is no stronger than regular-season flu,” said Janet Napolitano, homeland security secretary at a press conference in Washington in May.

Dr. Mark Pfitzner, director of the U’s Student Health Center, agrees with her. Pfitzner said the swine flu is just a typical viral infection that poses no general threat to students at the U. In fact, the U’s Student Health Center hasn’t had a single reported case of the swine flu. That’s not to say that there hasn’t been any students at the U who have had swine flu, but that it hasn’t been serious enough to draw attention.

That’s comforting news, considering that the one Utah man to die of swine flu was college age. Also comforting to hear is that swine flu was not the sole cause of his death. The 21-year-old, Marcos Antonio Sanchez, had chronic medical conditions that included respiratory problems.

People with such health issues constitute a high risk group that is more susceptible to any kind of flu.

“If you’re already sick, you can’t afford to get sicker, “said Dr. Kurt Peterson of Primary Children’s Hospital.

It seems as though the threat of swine flu has been over-dramatized, and with the attention it’s received from national and global agencies it’s not hard to understand why. On April 26, the U.S. Government declared swine flu a public health emergency. On June 11, the World Health Organization pushed the swine flu alert to Phase 6, indicating that a pandemic is underway.

Health emergency and pandemic seem to be strong words for a virus that reportedly is no more severe than the regular flu that comes through every year.

The swine flu has been classified as it has less because of what how the virus could affect our health, and more for what could be done with the media exposure.

Heightened concern about the swine flu has benefited the media with higher viewer ratings, the pharmaceutical companies with raised orders in flu treatments, and the Centers for Disease Control with more funding to test the virus.

In the words of Rahm Manuel, “Never waste a good crisis.”

letters@chronicle.utah.edu

Comments

8 comments
Delphie
Sat Jun 20 2009 16:08
Dave, you caught me ;)
Dave
Thu Jun 18 2009 21:12
Delphie, whats your Fark handle?
Oh, and...
Thu Jun 18 2009 20:46
I have my own observation re "Delphie": As he/she points out, you can't believe everything you read.... So maybe he/she had the swine flu twice and is just fine... and maybe not. [And Rob, I think what you have might be called the "wine flu." Who-o-ole different protocol for that. ;) ]
Rob
Thu Jun 18 2009 18:30
Dood im so worried OK i got drunk and fell down the stairs and herd a crack and therez a white thing sticking out of my arm is it swine flu?
Good luck
Thu Jun 18 2009 16:02
@Delphie: I'm glad you're fine after having had the swine flu. (Though perhaps with better hygiene, you wouldn't have had it twice.) Others might not be so lucky. The SLTribune and others are just quoting state and national epidemiologists and the Centers for Disease Control, nobody whose opinions matter or anything....
Delphie
Thu Jun 18 2009 13:55
I had the swine flu twice.

So I'm really getting a kick out of these replies.

Some of you are very good at making it sound like you know what you are talking about.

But you don't. Trust me.

I think some of you are just trying to make yourself sound clever.

This is how bad information gets passed around.

Don't try to make yourself sound like you know what you're talking about when you don't.

Because some people believe anything they read.

More info
Thu Jun 18 2009 13:08
Read "Utah health officials warn swine flu risk serious" in the Trib today:

...Utah has "one of, if not the most, active outbreaks in the country," state epidemiologist Robert Rolfs said Wednesday. And it's not clear why.

...One theory about why Utah seems to be suffering more from H1N1 is the state's younger population. Older people who have been exposed to several flus appear to have antibodies that help protect them, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Nathan Dean, chief of pulmonary critical care at Intermountain Medical Center in Murray and LDS Hospital in Salt Lake City, also hypothesizes that younger patients are having an "overreaction" to the virus, triggering a "vigorous inflammation response" that can cause septic shock and adult respiratory distress syndrome, which lands them in the hospital.

Irresponsible article
Thu Jun 18 2009 10:51
Much of this is already old data, and other info is misused/misunderstood by the author. More people have died here than 1 (8 in Utah as of yesterday)... and one of the main problems with swine flu (H1N1) is that it's novel--brand new--so no one has immunity to it. Also, a "pandemic" refers not to severity, but to spread; this is a pandemic because it very rapidly went global--it's very communicable, and quickly went everywhere. Plus it's out and about with H5N1 (avian flu) and the regular seasonal flu, along with West Nile (which it wouldn't normally interact with here). Almost all cases of flu in Utah are now thought to be H1N1. And people need to be putting safe practices in place now in preparation for if this gets worse--if any of the flus combine, or for how it might hit once our *normal flu season begins around November. Now is not the time to be telling people everything is fine. Keep washing your hands, avoid touching doorknobs and bannisters, cough and sneeze into a tissue or your elbow--and stay home if you're sick or have been around someone who is.






log out